Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
12" GF Special
Caesar
Crispy Chicken Sandwich
BLT
About
Pizza Sam Restaurant
Welcome to Pizza Sam Restaurant, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Alma, Michigan. Since 1960, this iconic establishment has captivated the taste buds of locals and visitors alike, offering an extraordinary pizza experience that is both nostalgic and comforting. Located at 104 E Superior St, Alma, MI 48801, Pizza Sam has become synonymous with high-quality, homemade pizza, prepared with a dedication that shines through in every slice.
What sets Pizza Sam apart is its commitment to authentic, New York-style pizza. As you take a bite of their signature Sam's Special, you’ll find the perfect balance of a thin, crunchy crust topped with a delectable combination of fresh ingredients. Customers rave about the phenomenal ham and pepperoni, especially when paired with their homemade French dip for crust dippings. It's a tradition that keeps patrons coming back for more, as echoed in Diana's glowing recommendation.
Even with its takeout-only format, Pizza Sam’s charm and quality are hard to overlook. The restaurant's reputation as a hidden gem is well-deserved; as Dark One states, “Everything is homemade, from the dough to the fresh toppings.” This commitment to freshness ensures that no bite is ever bland or artificial, with the flavors dancing harmoniously on your palate. And if you’re a fan of dipping sauces, their homemade blue cheese is a must-try, especially with crispy onion rings.
Customers like Quinn Keon have declared Pizza Sam as the best pizza around, after years of tastings from coast to coast. The enthusiastic feedback highlights the restaurant's top-notch ingredients and time-honored techniques, making it a staple for pizza enthusiasts near and far. Robby McCormick's fond memories of growing up with this pie evoke a sense of nostalgia that resonates with many. Although some have expressed a longing for dine-in experiences, the warm memories and exceptional flavors continue to draw people back—Alayna Bollinger drives an hour just for a taste of her childhood favorite!
Rest assured, the hustle and bustle of life won’t keep you from enjoying this incredible pizza. Pizza Sam offers delivery through DoorDash, bringing their mouthwatering creations straight to your doorstep, allowing you to savor old-school flavors in the comfort of your home. If you’re in the Alma area, this is one culinary adventure that you won't regret embarking upon. Pizza Sam Restaurant promises not just a meal, but an experience that will linger in your heart and on your palate long after the last slice has been devoured.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ My husband’s favorite is the Sam’s Special. Dipping the crust in the homemade French is where it’s at! The ham and pepperoni is phenomenal. Order an onion ring and dip them in the homemade blue cheese I am not a blue cheese fan unless it’s from pizza Sam’s with onion rings to dip. Highly recommend. Great owners, great food, great service. ”
“ Pizza Sam in Alma, Michigan, is one of my favorite pizza spots, and it's a true hidden gem. This place delivers an old-school pizza experience with a crunchy, thin crust that’s perfectly baked every time. Everything is homemade, from the dough to the fresh toppings, ensuring every bite is bursting with flavor. The ingredients are always top-notch, and you can really taste the difference in the quality and freshness of the toppings. While they operate as a takeout-only spot, Pizza Sam is well worth the visit, especially if you're craving a delicious, authentic, New York-style pizza. Their commitment to fresh, high-quality ingredients and old-school methods makes it stand out. Plus, they offer delivery through DoorDash, so you can enjoy their pizza from the comfort of your home. Pizza Sam’s has been a staple in Alma since 1960, and it's no surprise why it's a favorite among locals. If you’re in the area, I highly recommend checking them out—you won’t be disappointed! ”
“ I love this place! Grew up eating this pie! I love the crust and fresh topping! Keep up the good work. I always look forward to sams pizza. Wished you were open at lunch, but I understand. Thanks to the crew! ”
“ It's difficult to say that Pizza Sam is the best pizza on the planet because I haven't tried them all. However, I've eaten 50 pizzas in New York and Chicago and I've eaten 100 pizzas in California. I've tried every pizza in the central Michigan area and I'm typically disappointed when I'm eating any pizza that didn't come from Pizza Sam. They have the best crust, best sauce, best cheese, and best meat toppings. Are they the best on the planet? So far...yes. ”
“ I drive an hour back here to my hometown, just to get pizza! I’ve loved this place sense I was a kid, however I do wish they’d do dine in again, it was always the spot for my family and I to come together, especially when ones out of state came, we’d get a whole section for all of us. Will forever love pizza Sam’s, and will forever miss the dine in days! ”
“ We were originally from the area. We live 3 hours from Alma now. We've been wanting Sam's for a few years now. We made the trip today and it was worth it!!! Still our favorite pizza we've ever had anywhere in the country! ”
“ Best Pizza ever!!!! If they happen to be open when I visit my children in Ann Arbor, I pick pizzas up for them. Makes them VERY HAPPY!!!! ”
“ Pizza Sam's brings back soooooo many wonderful memories for me. When I lived in Alma and St. Louis, this place was an icon. You couldn't out do Pizza Sam's. The decor didn't change in the last 40 years and that's ok. From the swordfish on the wall to the mints on the counter, this place is the real deal. ”